PRIVACY POLICY
1. PURPOSE and SCOPE
As TALYA BİLİŞİM TİCARET VE SANAYİ A.Ş (“TALYA”, the “Company”), we attach importance to the protection of your personal data and private information. For this reason, our Company, in its capacity as Data Controller, makes every effort and exercises all due care to ensure that your personal data are processed in accordance with Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (the “KVK Law”, also referred to as KVKK, the Turkish Personal Data Protection Law), by being used, recorded, stored, updated, transferred and/or classified in connection with our business purposes within the framework described below.
In this context, in accordance with the laws and regulations enacted to protect the fundamental rights and freedoms of individuals, in particular the privacy of private life, and to protect personal data, our Company takes all technical and administrative measures to ensure an appropriate level of security in order to prevent the unlawful processing of your personal data, to prevent unlawful access to them and to ensure their safekeeping.
The target audience of this text is all natural persons whose personal data are processed on our websites and in our corporate processes, as well as our employees. As TALYA, we provide services through our online software delivered over the internet as web-based and cloud services (“Web-Based Software”), our desktop software (“Desktop”), our websites (“Site”, “Sites”) and our mobile applications (“Mobile Application”, “Mobile Applications”). This notice covers all of these software products, sites and applications.
Our web-based software: Elektraweb, Elektrawebmini, Elektraweb SPA, ElektraOtelimWebde
Desktop: Medisoft, Elektra
Our websites: www.talyabilisim.com.tr, www.medisoft.com.tr, isafe.com.tr, www.elektraotel.com, www.elektraweb.com, spasatis.com, sparezervasyon.com
Our mobile applications: Medisoft Mobil, Medisoft Mobil Pro, e-Cüzdan Mobil, Elektra Pos Restaurant Manager
Personal information processed on our software, applications, sites and mobile applications is processed in accordance with the legislation on the protection of personal data. With regard to our web-based, desktop and mobile applications, we have the status of “data controller” only in respect of those who open a user account and/or download the mobile applications and those who use our websites, and this Privacy Policy applies only to the processing of the data of these persons.
Our Customers who process and record data using our web-based, desktop and mobile applications are each data controllers independently of us. As in these cases we as the Company only have the status of “data processor”, we recommend that, where necessary, you refer to the privacy policies, information notices and similar documents of our Customers who process your personal data.
Furthermore, we give no guarantee regarding the data security and data protection practices and policies of third-party websites linked from our Sites. In this respect, we recommend that you separately review the data security and data protection policies of the relevant data controller.
3. IDENTITY OF THE DATA CONTROLLER
TALYA BİLİŞİM (or the “Organisation”) has the status of “Data Controller” towards all natural persons with whom it comes into contact and whose personal data it processes while conducting its commercial activities, in particular employees, job candidates, customers, suppliers, supplier employees and visitors, and is obliged to fulfil the obligations arising from the law. TALYA BİLİŞİM fulfils these obligations through administrative measures taken by means of the compliance and control tools it has adopted, together with appropriate and proportionate technical measures.
TALYA BİLİŞİM processes your personal data in its capacity as “Data Controller” as defined in Article 3 of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data; its contact details are as follows:
Company name: TALYA BİLİŞİM TİCARET VE SANAYİ A.Ş
Address: Akdeniz Üniversitesi Antalya Teknokenti, Ar-Ge 3 Binası, Dumlupınar Bulvarı, No:758/3 Kampüs ANTALYA
Our websites: www.talyabilisim.com.tr, www.medisoft.com.tr, isafe.com.tr, www.elektraotel.com, www.elektraweb.com, spasatis.com, sparezervasyon.com
Phone: + 90 (242) 227 91 00
You can send it to our correspondence address or by e-mail to our corporate e-mail address.
4. KEY CONCEPTS
Explicit consent: Consent relating to a specific matter, based on information and given of one's own free will
Anonymisation: Rendering personal data such that they can in no way be associated with an identified or identifiable natural person, even when matched with other data
Data subject: The natural person whose personal data are processed
Personal data: Any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person
Employee handling personal data: Employees who, by virtue of their job description, process the personal data of data subjects on behalf of the organisation
Processing of personal data: Any operation performed on data, such as obtaining, recording, storing, preserving, altering, reorganising, disclosing, transferring, taking over, making available, classifying or preventing the use of personal data, by wholly or partly automated means or by non-automated means provided that they form part of a data filing system
Committee: The internal Committee established within the organisation in accordance with the “Directive on the Duties and Responsibilities of the KVK Committee”, whose duties include monitoring all personal data processes carried out by the organisation, its units and employees, checking compliance with policies and conducting personal data processes on behalf of the organisation
Board: The Personal Data Protection Board
Authority: The Personal Data Protection Authority
KVK: Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data
Special Category Personal Data: Data relating to a person's race, ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion, sect or other beliefs, appearance and dress, membership of associations, foundations or trade unions, health, sexual life, criminal convictions and security measures, as well as biometric and genetic data
Data processor: The natural or legal person who processes personal data on behalf of the data controller on the basis of the authority granted by the data controller
Data filing system: A filing system in which personal data are structured and processed according to specific criteria
Data controller: The natural or legal person who determines the purposes and means of processing personal data and who is responsible for establishing and managing the data filing system
Joint data controller: Another data controller with whom the organisation shares personal data within the scope of its commercial and corporate activities and which jointly carries out processing activities on the personal data for the duration of this sharing.
Independent data controller: Another data controller with whom the organisation shares personal data on a one-off basis within the scope of its commercial and corporate activities.
5. PURPOSES OF PROCESSING PERSONAL DATA
In our organisation, the personal data of data subjects are processed, wholly and directly in connection with the organisation's activities and its commercial, business or legal relationship with the data subject, for the following purposes:
•Purposes related to Management Processes:
•Conducting commercial activities,
•Ensuring business continuity and legal and administrative business security,
•Planning and executing business and implementation strategies,
•Managing occupational health and safety processes,
•Giving presentations, promotion and information about the organisation, its services and products,
•Fulfilling obligations arising from legislation and contracts,
•Ensuring physical security within and around the organisation's premises,
•Obtaining legal support,
•Using electronic and other social media tools as well as printed, periodical and non-periodical publications,
•Conducting reseller processes
•Establishing and maintaining communication with members of the press and press and media organisations,
•Informing the public about activities,
•Holding business meetings in a timely and effective manner,
•Completing work in a timely and proper manner,
•Planning and conducting activities at local, national and international level,
•Managing relations with business partners and group companies in Turkey and abroad,
•Conducting transactions related to intellectual and industrial property,
•Carrying out promotion, marketing and information about the organisation, products and services,
•Receiving notifications and feedback from customers and potential customers,
•Providing technical support to customers,
•Answering questions from customers and potential customers
•Providing support for electronic invoicing services,
•Participating in events such as trade fairs and seminars,
•Purposes related to Employees:
•Drawing up and performing employees' employment contracts,
•Providing and implementing services offered to employees,
•Providing socio-economic benefits to employees,
•Conducting processes related to domestic and international assignments, travel and accommodation,
•Planning and conducting human resources processes,
•Recruitment, managing the employment relationship and conducting performance evaluation processes,
•Creating personnel files and storing them in physical and electronic media,
•Time and attendance tracking,
•Conducting exit procedures and exit interviews,
•Conducting performance and audit activities,
•Purposes related to IT Processes:
•Establishing and updating the IT and communication infrastructure,
•Managing users of IT tools and systems,
•Managing corporate e-mail accounts,
•Managing corporate social media accounts,
•Managing, auditing and closing the e-mail accounts of employees who leave,
•Managing, monitoring and auditing portable and/or desktop electronic devices,
•Conducting transactions of mobile application users,
•Conducting transactions relating to website members,
•Ensuring data security and archiving data,
•Keeping internet access logs,
•Tracking the organisation's vehicles and their users,
•Protecting and managing customers' digital assets and rights.
6. DATA SUBJECTS WHOSE PERSONAL DATA ARE PROCESSED
TALYA BİLİŞİM generally and mainly processes the data of data subjects within the scope of this Privacy Policy and other administrative and technical measures. The organisation's data processing policies, in particular this Privacy Policy, will also be complied with when processing the personal data of natural persons outside these categories. The categories of natural persons whose personal data are processed are as follows:
•Employees,
•Employees with open-ended employment contracts,
•Interns and participants in İŞKUR (Turkish Employment Agency) on-the-job training programmes,
•Job applicants,
•Customer representatives and employees,
•Supplier representatives and employees,
•Consultants and auditors,
•Public officials,
•Our visitors,
•Visitors to our websites,
•Potential customers and users,
•Our resellers
7. LEGAL GROUNDS AND CATEGORIES OF PERSONAL DATA PROCESSED
7.1. Personal Data of Our Employees, Our Employees Working under Open-Ended Employment Contracts and Interns
The organisation processes the personal data of employees, job candidates and interns in accordance with
•the Employment Contract,
•Labour Law No. 4857,
•Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098,
•Law No. 5510 on Social Insurance and General Health Insurance,
•Occupational Health and Safety Law No. 6331,
•Law No. 4632 on the Private Pension Savings and Investment System,
•Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004,
•Law No. 4904 on Certain Regulations concerning the Turkish Employment Agency,
•Vocational Training Law No. 3308,
•Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102,
•Electronic Signature Law No. 5070,
•Law No. 5651 on the Regulation of Publications on the Internet and Combating Crimes Committed by Means of Such Publications,
•the Regulation on Social Insurance Procedures,
•Identity Reporting Law No. 1774,
•the Regulation on the Payment of Wages, Premiums, Bonuses and All Similar Entitlements through Banks
and similar laws, regulations and communiqués.
In this context, the organisation processes employees' data in the categories of identity, contact, personnel, finance, professional experience, physical premises security, legal transactions, transaction security, risk management, visual and audio recordings and other information, as well as special category data such as belief, association membership, foundation membership, health information, criminal convictions and security measures.
7.2. Personal Data of Job Applicants
We process personal data such as identity, personnel, contact, family information, finance, education, professional experience and habits that job applicants share with us of their own accord by means such as CVs and cover letters, or that are shared with us by online employment platforms and/or talent agencies to which they have submitted them of their own accord for sharing with all relevant organisations, as well as special category data, such as association and foundation memberships, that they have recorded in their CVs and likewise shared of their own accord.
7.3. Personal Data of Representatives of Our Customers and Suppliers
The organisation processes the personal data of the customers and suppliers who are natural persons with whom it establishes relationships while conducting its commercial activities, and of the representatives and natural persons of customer and supplier organisations, in accordance with
•the Service Agreement,
•Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098,
•Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004,
•Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102,
•Tax Procedure Law No. 213,
•the General Communiqués on the Tax Procedure Law
and similar laws, regulations and communiqués. The organisation processes personal data of natural-person customers and suppliers and their representatives in the categories of identity, contact, finance, legal transactions and other information.
7.4. Personal Data of Auditors, Consultants and Public Employees
In order to conduct its commercial and production activities and to ensure their sustainability and quality, the organisation processes the personal data of auditors, consultants and public employees who carry out control and audit duties in accordance with
•Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102,
•Customs Law No. 4458,
•Tax Procedure Law No. 213,
•Labour Law No. 4857,
•Law No. 4904 on Certain Regulations concerning the Turkish Employment Agency,
•Law No. 5510 on Social Insurance and General Health Insurance,
•the General Communiqués on the Tax Procedure Law,
and similar laws, regulations and communiqués.
In this context, the organisation processes the personal data of auditors, consultants and public officials in the categories of identity, contact and personnel.
7.5. Personal Data of Our Application and Site Users
We process personal data in the categories of identity, personnel, contact and location of users who use our own web-based, desktop and mobile applications on their own behalf or on behalf of an organisation.
In addition, a trial account is created for persons who wish to try our applications and software, and their personal data in the categories of identity, personnel and contact are processed.
7.6. Personal Data of Our Visitors
In order to ensure IT and premises security, we process the personal data of visitors within the scope of
•Law No. 5651 on the Regulation of Publications on the Internet and Combating Crimes Committed by Means of Such Publications,
and on the basis of our legitimate interest.
In this context, visitors' personal data in categories such as Identity, Transaction Security and Physical Premises Security are processed.
7.7. Personal Data of Site Visitors and Members
On the basis of our legitimate interest, personal data in categories such as transaction security and identity of users who visit our websites and register as members are processed by means of forms and “cookies”. For more information on cookies, please refer to our “Cookie Policy”.
7.8. Personal Data of Our Potential Customers
Apart from advertisements on our Sites, we may inform our users, trial version users, customers and potential customers about new products or services by e-mail, social media or telephone, after obtaining their consent. Data subjects may object to such promotional, advertising and marketing communications at any time. In addition, data subjects who do not wish to receive our e-mails and SMS messages of this kind can block the messages, use the unsubscribe option or contact us and ask to be removed from the lists.
We also have a newsletter to inform those interested in our products and/or services. Each newsletter contains a link through which you can unsubscribe from our newsletter. Those who wish to unsubscribe can also do so via their account settings. Limited to this scope, we process the personal data of our potential customers in the categories of identity, personnel and contact.
7.9. Personal Data of Our Resellers
The organisation processes the identity, contact and personnel data of the representatives of our resellers who take part in the sales, marketing and after-sales support of our products and services in accordance with
•the Reseller Agreement
•Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098,
•Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004,
•Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102,
•Tax Procedure Law No. 213,
•the General Communiqués on the Tax Procedure Law
and similar laws, regulations and communiqués
8. RIGHTS OF THE DATA SUBJECT
The organisation acknowledges that, under the Law, the data subject has the right to give consent before data are processed and, after the data have been processed, the right to determine what happens to their data.
In this sense, data subjects may apply to the Contact Person and exercise the rights to:
•a) learn whether your personal data are being processed,
•b) request information about it if your personal data have been processed,
•c) learn the purpose of processing of your personal data and whether they are used in accordance with that purpose,
ç) know the third parties to whom personal data are transferred in Turkey or abroad,
•d) request the rectification of personal data if they have been processed incompletely or incorrectly,
•e) request the erasure or destruction of personal data within the framework of the conditions laid down in Article 7 of the Law,
•f) request that the operations carried out pursuant to sub-paragraphs (d) and (e) be notified to third parties to whom the personal data have been transferred,
•g) object to a result arising to your detriment through the analysis of the processed data exclusively by automated systems,
ğ) claim compensation for damages if you suffer damage due to the unlawful processing of personal data.
However, persons have no rights in relation to anonymised data within the Company. Personal data may be shared with the relevant institutions and organisations where required by the business and contractual relationship or where a judicial or public authority exercises a legal power.
Requests within the scope of the listed rights are made by completing the organisation's Application Form in full and sending it, with your wet signature, by registered mail with return receipt together with copies of your identity document (for the identity card, a copy of the front side only) to the Contact Person. For the application process, you can consult the Information Notice on Personal Data Applications.
9. BASIC RULES TO BE FOLLOWED IN THE PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA
When processing the personal data of data subjects, TALYA BİLİŞİM units and employees shall take care to observe the following basic rules, on which the Privacy Policy and other corporate policies are also built.
•Compliance with the law and the rules of good faith: The organisation checks and questions whether the conditions specified in the KVK, such as informing the data subject and, where necessary, obtaining the data subject's explicit consent for processing, have been fulfilled for the personal data it collects itself or that other parties share with it. It acts in accordance with the rules of good faith when informing data subjects, obtaining their explicit consent or responding to their requests for information.
•Being accurate and, where necessary, up to date: The organisation endeavours to ensure that the personal data it processes and keeps in its databases contain accurate information to the extent permitted by its control mechanisms. It takes care to keep data up to date as far as possible. It encourages data sources to share accurate information and to provide updates when changes occur. It takes care to check that data are accurate and up to date at the time of collection.
•Processing for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes: The organisation processes personal data only for the specified, explicit and legitimate purposes set out in this Privacy Policy.
•Being relevant, limited and proportionate to the purposes for which they are processed: The organisation takes care not to process personal data for any purpose outside the limits of the purpose for which they are processed and, where such a need arises, to inform the data subject and, where necessary, to obtain their explicit consent. It uses data only to the extent limited to the purpose of processing and as required by the service. It does not process, use or allow the use of data outside business purposes. Where personal data need to be processed for another purpose, corrections are made to the relevant compliance and control tools under the supervision and with the approval of the Committee.
•Retention limited to the necessary period: The organisation takes care to retain personal data for as long as stipulated in the relevant legislation or as necessary for the purpose for which they are processed. It retains personal data arising from contracts for the limitation periods for disputes under the relevant Laws and as required by commercial and tax law. However, when these purposes cease to exist, the organisation erases or anonymises the personal data. How long data in each category will be retained is determined in the Personal Data Inventory.
•Data minimisation: The organisation, its units and employees collect data in the categories relevant to the purpose, only in the quantity required by the purpose of processing, apart from the scope and periods made mandatory by law and the relevant legislation, and take care to process them in their systems only for as long as necessary.
•Erasure and destruction: The organisation stores the personal data it processes for periods limited to those stipulated in the laws to which it is subject and in the relevant legislation such as social security, obligations, tax and commercial law, and/or for the periods required by the purpose of processing. When these periods expire, it erases, destroys or anonymises the expired personal data in accordance with the Personal Data Retention, Erasure, Destruction and Transfer Policy and with the permission and under the supervision of the Committee.
•Confidentiality and data security: Throughout all processes of processing, transferring and storing personal data, the organisation takes care to comply with general confidentiality rules and to ensure data security, and acts in accordance with the policy documents and rules established for this purpose. Care is taken to implement the necessary administrative and technical measures.
10. TRANSFER OF PERSONAL DATA
In order to carry out its production-oriented and commercial activities and to ensure the performance of specialised activities it needs as an organisation, TALYA BİLİŞİM uses service and product suppliers in Turkey and abroad and may transfer personal data to these suppliers, business partners or authorised institutions and organisations, which are deemed “data processors”, “data controllers” or “joint data controllers” depending on their job descriptions, activities and the nature of the service they provide. It may forward the e-mail addresses of our users to third-party companies with which we cooperate.
10.1. Points to Be Observed in the Transfer of Personal Data
•When sharing personal data, the data transfer is secured by signing a data transfer agreement, letter of undertaking or similar documents with all parties to whom data are transferred.
•Each unit and employee must consider in advance the risks that the recipient of the personal data transfer may create with regard to personal data and must take care to prevent situations that would create risk.
•When using applications and services of foreign origin, care is taken to comply with the relevant legislation such as the KVK and the GDPR.
•During data transfers to parties and suppliers, it is mandatory to ensure that data security is maintained using appropriate and secure tools and channels, to monitor whether the natural persons to whom personal data are transferred have been authorised by the recipient, and to ensure that any copies and duplicates of personal data created for the purpose of the transfer are deleted from all media as soon as their function has ended.
•The organisation's units and employees are obliged to monitor the sensitivity and practices regarding personal data of the parties and suppliers to whom they transfer data and to report situations that may pose a risk to their superiors in a timely manner. The organisation's employees should request the necessary support from their superiors in a timely manner regarding situations and problems concerning personal data that they cannot resolve.
10.2. Cases in Which Personal Data Are Transferred and Parties to Whom They Are Transferred
Personal data are shared for the purposes specified below with the parties also specified below:
•Where necessary for the planning and performance of the commercial activities carried out by the organisation, to private institutions and organisations such as group companies, business partners, affiliates, consultancy firms and other service suppliers in Turkey and abroad, as well as to public institutions and organisations,
•To natural and legal persons providing services in these areas, and to the third parties they work with, for ensuring business continuity, ensuring legal, technical and commercial business security, and planning and executing human resources, occupational health and safety and emergency processes and strategies;
•To persons with whom the organisation has signed contracts within the framework of the services it procures, and to the third parties they work with,
•To suppliers providing external services as part of the services offered by the organisation or providing socio-economic benefits to employees, and to the third parties they work with,
•During recruitment and exit processes, to departments within the organisation, our group companies and previous or subsequent employers,
•Where necessary for the organisation to fulfil its legal obligations, to our business partners, consultancy firms, suppliers, private institutions and organisations, courts, public institutions and organisations and competent authorities,
•To the relevant banks for the payment and collection transactions required for the conclusion and performance of contracts entered into by the organisation,
•To insurance agencies and insurance companies so that employees can benefit from insurance and similar rights
•To law firms, accounting/certified public accountant (SMM) offices, lawyers and other consultants in order to obtain legal and financial support in connection with the establishment, exercise and protection of our organisation's rights,
•To service suppliers in Turkey and abroad providing cloud services, for the infrastructure and services required for corporate electronic communication channels and for ensuring data security;
•To platforms and applications of foreign origin from which we procure services in order to use online communication channels and tools such as instant messaging, file sharing, video conferencing and e-mail,
•To the supplier from which we obtain services for the provision and authorisation of electronic signatures,
•To supplier organisations providing services in these areas, so that support messages can be sent on employees' special days, events can be organised and successful employees can be rewarded, in order to increase employee motivation and strengthen team spirit,
•To the auditors carrying out audits and to audit organisations of domestic or foreign origin, so that audits on quality, social and other matters undergone by the organisation or conducted at the request of customers can be carried out,
•To private and public institutions/organisations for the conduct of legal and technical processes relating to work and transactions concerning intellectual and industrial property.
10.3. Transfer of Personal Data Abroad
Personal data will be shared with the following parties established abroad for the purpose of providing services through cloud, instant messaging or online communication channels, which are widely and unavoidably used today. In this context, personal data are shared
•with Microsoft, of US origin, for office work and operations,
•with Facebook, of US origin, via the WhatsApp application as an instant messaging application in business relationships between employees and with customers,
•with Google, WeTransfer and Microsoft, of US origin, for sharing large files for business purposes,
•with Microsoft, of US origin, via Azure, which provides data centre and cloud server services,
•with Constant Contact, of US origin, for bulk e-mail management,
•with Tawk.to, of US origin, to provide customers with live support via the website,
•with Ammy, of US origin, and Anydesk and Teamviewer, of German origin, which provide remote access, to provide technical support to customers,
•with Microsoft, of US origin, via the Skype application for video conferencing services,
•with Google, of US origin, and Yandex, of Russian origin, for our corporate e-mail services, and with Twilio via the SendGrid application, which provides e-mail server services,
•with Apple, of US origin, and Microsoft and Google, of US origin, which provide mobile and desktop operating systems, for conducting day-to-day business activities,
•with Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Linkedin, of US origin, which provide social media services from abroad, and with Google, of US origin, via Youtube.
You can access the privacy policies of each service provider at the following links:
•Microsoft (https://privacy.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement)
•Whatsapp (https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/client)
•Google (https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US)
•Wetransfer (https://wetransfer.com/legal/privacy)
•Constant Contact (https://www.endurance.com/privacy/privacy)
•to (https://www.tawk.to/privacy-policy/)
•Ammy (https://www.ammyy.com/en/priv_policy.html)
•Anydesk (https://anydesk.com/en/privacy)
•Teamviewer (https://www.teamviewer.com/en/privacy-policy/)
•Skype (https://support.skype.com/en/skype/all/privacy-security/)
•Yandex (https://yandex.com.tr/support/legal/confidential/01032016/index.html?lang=en)
•Twilio (https://www.twilio.com/legal/privacy)
•Apple (https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/)
•Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/policy.php)
•Twitter (https://twitter.com/en/privacy)
•Instagram (https://help.instagram.com/519522125107875)
•Linkedin (https://www.linkedin.com/legal/privacy-policy)
•Sharethis (https://sharethis.com/privacy/)
•Cloudflare (https://www.cloudflare.com/privacypolicy/)
11. AUDITS, APPLICATIONS AND DATA BREACH NOTIFICATIONS
The organisation may have the necessary internal and external audits carried out regarding the protection of personal data.
Applications made by data subjects are answered by the Committee within 30 days at the latest, after obtaining the opinion of the relevant unit.
When the organisation is notified of any breach concerning personal data, it notifies the KVK Board without delay and within 72 hours at the latest from the date on which it became aware of the breach. It informs the relevant parties and persons in the same way.
12. UPDATES
This policy document is updated when the organisation's personal data processing conditions, tools, purposes and scope change, and when the parties with whom personal data are shared change. Updates made to each article are kept in a separate table.